Survivor
Survivor
1
~ survivor ~ 2 months ago
The problem with the fire-making challenge

Some spoilers below, FYI!

I understand initially why the fire-making challenge was introduced. It was a way to make the finale a little bit more dramatic, particularly given the longer seasons allowed for stronger alliances that made the final three a little more obvious. A semi-random challenge thrown in at the end created more tension, and more surprises.

Now that the seasons are shorter, I'm not sure why we continue having it be such a key moment for the game. Especially when juries imply the final immunity winner needs to give up their immunity and make fire in order to prove themselves.

It made sense when Chris Underwood did it first — given he was absent from most of the game, he needed a big moment to show the jury he could be a contender. But the jury implying that it was a mistake for Cassie keep her immunity, even though she had already won three individual challenges? For one, Cassie had nothing to prove, competition-wise — she had already shown she could outplay others. And if this game is also about outwitting the competition, why would anyone give up a 1/3 shot to win for a 50% chance of losing? Particularly when that loss is often up to chance — the wind blows the wrong way, and you're cut from final tribal.

Given this, at this point, there is little reward for winning the final individual immunity. And, what's more, fire-making becomes less and less interesting to watch as the seasons wear on. It's time for something new, even if that something new is going back to basics during a shorter season.

Open Post
1
~ survivor ~8 months ago
If you were to pick two cast members from 42…
On 'Survivor,' Advantages Alone Can’t Save You
This week’s Survivor reminds me why it’s nice to have some people that are just not that good at this game in the mix: they keep things interesting.
Brit Starna
Evvie, Tiffany, & Naseer Are Now Big Fish Who Need Bigger Ponds
On Survivor this week, the main takeaway for me is that I am READY for this merge to happen.
Brit Starna
Is Shan One Of The Best Social Players, Ever?
On this week’s episode of Survivor 41, Luvu tribe couldn’t lose if they wanted to, Yase came out on top for once, and the assassin of Ua emerged: pastor Shan.
Brit Starna
On 'Survivor,' JD Seems To Be Getting A Hell Of An Edit
Survivor, father of all reality competitions, finally returned for its 41st (!!!) season after a staggering 16-month drought.
Brit Starna