We've heard it for weeks now: Clayton falls in love with three women and tells two of them that he was "intimate with both of you" toward the end of his Bachelor journey. We now know that the three women are Gabby, Rachel, and Susie, but aside from that, not much else is known, and The Women Tell All episode just made things even more confusing.

It has already seemed like Clayton is going to leave The Bachelor without the traditional engagement situation. Not only have the trailers repeatedly shown everyone crying without a proposal platform by a noisy beach in sight, but series creator Mike Fleiss tweeted this two weeks ago:

"Major Historic Announcement! This season’s finale of #TheBachelorABC is totally spoiler-proof. No one knows how it will end, cuz it ain’t over til it’s over! And it ain’t over…"

Now, on top of that, the Women Tell All has made it seem like Clayton does something awful... but also that we should feel sympathy for him? I think?

As the special wraps up, Sierra — the star of the episode, who is going to rule the beach in Paradise — interrupts Clayton and host Jesse Palmer and says, "Speaking on the fact that you fell in love with three women, you obviously know that we are all very close. All of us women are very close. And a few of us have been able to hear about what goes down and how messy it gets. And I want to know exactly who are you to act a certain way, and treat these women a certain way, and subject them to this kind of behavior of yours? Like, what did they do to deserve it?"