Ever since Sydney and Gary hooked up on their first free night on the yacht, she’s been following him around like a lost puppy. While he tried to make it clear during their lil romp that it was just a one-time thing, her confessionals have been all about how she can’t get a read on his vibe. Well, that’s not exactly the case. She’s made it clear that she is picking up what he’s putting down, she’s just not fully ready to give up hope — even as he moves on to Alli, one of Sydney and Gary's other coworkers. But as fans call out her “desperate” behavior, a new episode of Below Deck Sailing Yacht may have just muddied the waters.

The Monday, April 5, installment of the Bravo TV show, aptly titled “Throuple Trouble,” continued to follow the awkwardness between Sydney, Gary, and Alli… but it also introduced an interesting new element. While Gary seems to only have eyes for Alli these days, he also seemed to be encouraging Sydney to stick around and make it a group hang instead of seizing the opportunity for some one on one time. There was plenty of flirting to go around, but the question is whether it was all one-sided on Sydney’s end or if Gary is actually sending mixed signals. With the crew drama heating up, it’s time to dive into the evidence and see how it lays out.