Team Molly as well! Also, her winter outfit looks terrific on kitties!!!!

Before I answer, are we talking the OG girls? Or like any of the girls?

I get the Molly love, but Samantha always has to be number one here. She had a rich girl’s wardrobe — there’s no beating that. 

they all looked ug! dolls are supposed to be aspirational, and all these girls look like they're fighting for their lives. I never had one and i'll be honest, these pics aren't selling me on one now either 

They were all terribly dressed boring dolls. Barbies and Bratz worst outfit could eat them up on their best day. They were also overpriced and depressing tbh no personality you couldn’t even play with them!  They didn’t have American boy dolls or if they did no one cared about them. I’m so glad they’ve been phased out. Even Polly pocket could put a better outfit together! 

Kit: She's got a weird hat and a ring!?!? SHOW HER SOME RESPECT. 

Molly: books... A lamp? And a patriotic robe. NERD ALERT.

Samantha: a fancy desk, a velvet purse, an umbrella! RICH GIRL!

Felicity: poor girl, she was a pioneer so no accessories for her. Yellow fever was her accessory. 

Kirsten: a bonnet, a little pouch for her hopes and dreams. But she did have cute room accessories. 

Which American Girl doll has the most enviable wardrobe? 

5. Kirsten: Who let you out of the house in an apron?! Everything about Kirsten was a huge bummer, as was her dreadful fashion. Even the holiday wreath crown was giving too much. One can be too much extra.

https://americangirl.fandom.com/wiki/Kirsten_Larson_

https://americangirl.fandom.com/wiki/Saint_Lucia_Gown

4. Felicity: I'll never forget that she had a hard, plastic insert with her dress that kind of seemed like the thing you put in your teeth for dental x-rays. Also, she had fabulous red hair, but covered it with a bonnet that looked like a pot holder. 

https://americangirl.fandom.com/wiki/Laced_Jacket_and_Petticoat

3. Addy: Addy showed Kirsten and Felicity how bonnets SHOULD be styled. Seriously, I could see Carrie Bradshaw in that straw bonnet and big bow TODAY. She's only downgrade for her school uniform, which I wouldn't wish on Rory Gilmore.  

https://americangirl.fandom.com/wiki/Addy_Walker_

https://americangirl.fandom.com/wiki/School_Suit_and_Blouse

2. Samantha: I feel like it's controversial to make Samantha number two, but that's primarily because she's way too rich to be in that muted checkered mess in the first book. (And she could also use a little less sleeve.) But her winter coat and muff... chef's kiss. So chic. 

https://americangirl.fandom.com/wiki/Plaid_Cape_and_Gaiters

1. Molly: I have done a total 180 on Molly since I was a kid. I couldn't get on board with the glasses initially, but her outfit is straight out of Emily in Paris 2022. And while her camp outfit should be set on fire immediately, the stars and stripes outfit was a SHOW. STOPPER.

https://www.collegefashion.net/inspiration/fashion-inspiration-american-girl-doll-molly/

https://americangirl.fandom.com/wiki/Molly%27s_Miss_Victory_Costume

Best-dressed American Girl?

Exclusive interviews and commentary about some of our favorite shows from the '90s and 2000s.