Natalie. Always Natalie. Shayne is definitely stretching the narrative.

I feel like Sal was being honest. I don't see him as lying for drama's sake, as flawed as that relationship was. 

Just watched After the Altar and I can’t really decide who’s telling the truth: Is Shane or Natalie telling the truth? Is Mal or Sal?

I feel like Netflix would show us the flirtatious DMs between Shayne and Shaina if they existed… that said, I think Natalie said they were deleted. 

I’m apt to believe Sal’s version of the shopping excursion gone wrong… I just don’t feel like he’s a liar. But idk!!!

Who do we believe?

Allison Piwowarski

News, commentary, and exclusives for Netflix's dating reality show, 'Love Is Blind.'